{
  "review_type": "internal Codex independent model/numerical review, not external peer review",
  "verdict": "GO for sealed v2 nominal-calendar model results; no numerical or method blockers",
  "checked_utc": "2026-10-30T17:22:07.605245+00:00",
  "plan_sha256": "07add03f2e9de805f1170f0aebaa29dfb157443b5d93d83a877f3ffde1ddaa53",
  "runner_sha256": "2bcb9e611039bb450cb70aa072f03f32d65b9fea9f4d9a95bf99b0fe23fdcaec",
  "total_comparisons": 830790,
  "issues": [],
  "conditions": 50,
  "permutations": 49950,
  "all_original_conditions_exact_match": 50,
  "preselected_full_slot_permutations_exact_match": 7,
  "daily_exact_summary_rows_checked": 18245,
  "daily_cumulative_rows_checked": 18245,
  "nominal_scenario_slots_checked": 875760,
  "primary_median_original_to_reference_ratio": 1.1074194669490707,
  "primary_years_above_reference_median": 10,
  "primary_ratio_range": [
    1.026863069161585,
    1.2781301832123924
  ],
  "public_wording": "Across ten annual nominal profiles, the median original/reference capacity ratio was 1.1074 (10.7% higher). The reference is 999 within-month whole-day permutations per year in a declared lossless, unlimited-power nominal-calendar model.",
  "publication_scope": [
    "Nominal calendar and 0.5 nominal-hour slot weights must remain explicit in headline context, figures and capacity units.",
    "Source physical UTC timeline was not repaired or validated; original v1 abort/revision disclosed.",
    "No actual-France storage requirement, causal inference, calibrated p-value, whole-hypothesis refutation or novelty claim.",
    "The 90/10 sensitivity has one annual ratio below 1 (2016, 0.9839889730598103); all sensitivities retained."
  ],
  "limitations": [
    "Seven selected full-slot permutation capacities were independently regenerated, not all49950; every retained row seed, unit conversion and every output summary was checked.",
    "Source physical UTC timeline remains unresolved; v2 uses declared nominal slot weights.",
    "This checks internal numerical consistency and declared model implementation, not independent validation of source measurements or external peer review."
  ],
  "evidence_sha256": {
    "independent-numerical-audit-v2.json": "165ebceeb967b68b613aa2f9a925550fcaf87ad2c96d455fd0b6da9f36d22be5",
    "independent-table-audit-v2.json": "7595ca1d53db6d4c6460fc4b6d30119950eebe57a3450440ac1662f9fc99135d",
    "independent-data-preflight-v2.json": "320d94beb3955ba3bd2def2b35a46e0698379900fbbb20ae6890c0465af4470c",
    "independent-calendar-diagnostic.json": "e37c84567baa3dec3e4ccbbd2e12e7123f84885934ad8ac1fa95db496c9b1ee9",
    "execution-approval-v2.json": "60ed2ad66f67cd82f85ae44fbcb75dd76517289ca5fc043c299f078ca91e4444"
  },
  "reader_facing_review": {
    "review_type": "internal Codex reader-facing scope and figure-label review, not external peer review",
    "reviewed_utc": "2026-10-30T17:25:08.558855+00:00",
    "verdict": "GO",
    "material_blockers": [],
    "review_scope": "HTML reader-facing text, Blogger draft and SVG text labels; not rendered-layout or bibliography/source-literature review",
    "files": [
      {
        "path": "outputs/storage-chronology-test-20261030/index.html",
        "sha256": "b262098f242708c98244c02bae5613ff7c6c7490d1b2b8d6d341bba8ed36256e"
      },
      {
        "path": "outputs/storage-chronology-test-20261030/report.html",
        "sha256": "faf22553715f749c570cd28fd660a89a2d10223438c466280a4e3136e9874cb3"
      },
      {
        "path": "outputs/storage-chronology-test-20261030/figures/capacity-all-scenarios.svg",
        "sha256": "bbd9903b2ab8e3d5dcdced38001bc0d15da6a1e3f78b2361a5980a35bca0632c"
      },
      {
        "path": "outputs/storage-chronology-test-20261030/figures/capacity-primary.svg",
        "sha256": "c7aaa6b347f94fda49de723cd9af4685284473acd1026896586f9e32bba086d5"
      },
      {
        "path": "outputs/storage-chronology-test-20261030/figures/deterministic-control.svg",
        "sha256": "7b43662527a58a9883ea2c0f3f0a0dbce4c836a0cec49ad1f6aefce964dde83f"
      },
      {
        "path": "outputs/storage-chronology-test-20261030/figures/ratios-all-scenarios.svg",
        "sha256": "061e3db8e6e4a2335633ebacafff49525104aff192fba577795f7b53210bd4ff"
      },
      {
        "path": "outputs/blogger-storage-chronology-test.html",
        "sha256": "d75417e84a05e95942075b2a02907b92e53876380334aec75d19f3d0b9a20ccd"
      }
    ],
    "checks": [
      "Primary headline explicitly nominal model and median of annual original/reference ratios",
      "Physical clock preflight failure and pre-outcome revision disclosed",
      "Signed source values and transformed sensitivities separated",
      "All five scenario aggregates match audited output, including90/10 exception",
      "Reference intervals/ranks explicitly descriptive and not confidence intervals or calibrated p-values",
      "No actual-France energy/storage, whole duration-aware hypothesis refutation, causality or novelty claim",
      "Internal Codex review clearly distinguished from external peer review",
      "Data limitation is framed as failed physical-time assumption, not an accusation of RTE source fault"
    ],
    "publication_sequence_condition": "Blogger statement that reproducible files are public must follow successful verification of the linked public packet."
  }
}